Is there any area of anything that isn’t corrupted by money [he asks rhetorically]?

Dr. Andrew Wakefield’s 1998 report in the journal Lancet purporting to show a link between autism and the vaccine for measles, mumps and rubella “was based not on bad science but on a deliberate fraud,” says Dr. Fiona Godlee, editor in chief of BMJ, formerly the British Medical Journal, in an editorial published Tuesday. The editorial accompanies the first of three reports by British investigative journalist Brian Deer that document how Wakefield manipulated data in his attempts to prove something that he “knew” before he started his research. Most of the information in the reports has been published previously, but the recent publication of the General Medical Council’s 6-million-word transcript of the hearing in which Wakefield’s license to practice medicine in Britain was revoked allowed the editors of BMJ to peer-review Deer’s reports and confirm the extensive falsifications in the original Lancet paper.
[…]
The original paper authored by Wakefield and 12 others involved 12 children with autism, nine of them with a regressive form in which the children begin to develop normally, then lose speech or other faculties. The average delay between vaccination and onset of autism in eight of the children was 6.3 days, the authors reported, and the parents were said to blame the vaccine.

But, Deer finds:
–Only one of the nine children who supposedly had regressive autism actually did. Three did not have autism at all.
–Five of the children had preexisting developmental problems, despite the paper’s claims that all were normal prior to vaccination.
–Although the paper claimed an average of 6.3 days between vaccination and the onset of symptoms, some children did not show symptoms until months later.




  1. Thomas says:

    #32
    Since all deities are fictions, all religions (based on deities) are scams.

  2. ECA says:

    If nothing ELSE..

    REDO the experiment..
    PROVE IT..again.

  3. Olo Baggins of Bywater says:

    soundwash…see Chris #10. That crowd was itching for a scapegoat, and they got one. Being a noisy group, and unfazed by follow-ups, the story still has legs in parenting and autism circles.

  4. foobar says:

    Alfred hauled out the Cambrian explosion, a hologram and the matrix. That made my day. Next thing you know people will be claiming that Johnny Weir is gay.

  5. tcc3 says:

    @foobar

    At least hes not inciting violence today.

  6. foobar says:

    tcc3, giggle.

  7. So what says:

    Alfred1 Read Stephen J Gould’s Wonsderful Life, Edward O Wilson’s The Diversity of Life, and Edey and Johanson’s Bluprints then get back to us.

  8. Improbus says:

    I see Alfred escaped from the Asylum and started posting again.

  9. foobar says:

    Is Alfred1 and Alfred Persson the same person. Different aspects to a multiple personality but the same biological entity? Or potential carbon based form of life?

  10. President Amabo says:

    Vacines cause Global Warming(c)(TM)

  11. foobar says:

    It’s so hard to tell you apart. It must have the bewildering birther comment on a British vaccine research thread.

  12. foobar says:

    Seriously, any tips from anybody? How do you tell bipolar depressive, religious nut cases apart? Is it the wacky new age bible science? The homophobia? The old man lust for Bristol Palin?

    Inquiring minds want to know.

  13. Thomas says:

    #53
    That only one that would be hurt by exposure here is your psychiatrist. If you are sane, go to a real college and take some courses in chemistry, physics and biology then get back to us on your views on evolution and the scientific method. Until then, up your meds.

  14. foobar says:

    Alfred Persson, wow. That was the first hint of humanity I’ve ever seen out of you. Nicely done.

  15. moondawg says:

    #34, I’m sure your “evidence” is every bit as compelling as theirs.

  16. pedro's confused donkey says:

    #57

    Alfred

    You really should take your meds. You are a walking, talking, advertisement for universal health care AND psychiatric commitment.

  17. foobar says:

    #60 Wow, what a whining liberal. Who’s posting under a different name?

  18. Named says:

    Is it true? Has Alfred E Newman finally left for good?

    Oh, happy days!

  19. foobar says:

    Named, never say never. Personally, I enjoy poking him – metaphorically of course.

  20. So what says:

    Alfred is gone!!!!!!! How will I ever survive? All of my beliefs in science will not be dismissed willy nilly as an irrational belief in an unproven, unseen mechanism that affects my life, um wait a second on second thought.

  21. pedro's confused donkey says:

    Alfred is gone??? Gee, was it something I said?


0

Bad Behavior has blocked 5873 access attempts in the last 7 days.