San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors voted today to require all businesses and residences to recycle and compost their garbage or face fines, which could lead to a lien on their property.
The ordinance, approved in a 9-2 vote, will force building owners to sign up for the city’s existing composting and recycling programs. The Board will deliver a final vote on the ordinance next week.
“Many tenants want to recycle and compost but the building does not offer the service,” Mayor Gavin Newsom said in a statement. “We’re going to change that.”
The city could enforce the ordinance with citations and penalties that “could not exceed $1,000, although the Directors could by regulation cap penalties at lower levels,” it said. The ordinance specifically pegs fines for buildings generating less than a cubic yard of trash per week, such as single-family homes, at less than $100.
Other cities, notably Seattle and San Diego, have mandatory recycling laws in place but fines are rarely leveled. Unpaid fines in San Francisco could lead to lien proceedings.
San Francisco generates some 2 million tons of solid waste annually, according to the city, but it also enjoys the highest waste diversion rate in the country — 70 percent. By 2020, the city wants to send no waste to landfill.
Green Biz – June 9, 2009:
1
Support the Blog — Buy This Book!
For Kindle and with free ePub version. Only $9.49 Great reading.
Here is what Gary Shapiro CEO of the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) said: Dvorak's writing sings with insight and clarity. Whether or not you agree with John's views, he will get you thinking and is never boring. These essays are worth the read!
Put this ad on your blog!
Syndicate
Subscribe to Main Blog feed here:
Subscribe to Comments too (below):
Junk Email Filter
The war on simple freedom continues…
Overdue.
When you live in a state that is running a deficit larger than the GDP of many nations, the best thing to do is mandate recycling programs that usually cost more than they return.
Americans don’t like recycling. We like storing dead bodies in underground boxes made of toxic materials and concrete. Nature / God does it automatically but because we are out of the loop we need incentives and government mandates.
For those of the stupid persuasion: Don’t sh*t where you eat.
If an individual composts their waste and resells it as fertilizer, will they have to pay a $461 vendor permit to do it?
#3, Deficit spending is the way out of debt. Don’t you know anything? Gosh!
[sarcasm mode off]
#6 ROFL!
Constantly amazes me that people voluntarily choose to live in a city like this.
So you guys mean that personal freedom is about choice to pollute?
Morons!
“By 2020, the city wants to send no waste to landfill.”
Translation. By 2010 we intend to offer no waste service for the monthly fee we extort from businesses and consumers in San Fransisco.
Can you imagine the piles of garbage that will be accumulating in yards and businesses around the city as people heap crap into compost mounds. Dead fish, chicken nuggets, tin cans and whatever people hurl into these compost piles.
I suspect it will make no difference as San Fransisco will probably be the first city in California to legalize drugs. They will all sit around stoned having gay sex and wallowing in the stinking garbage that will certainly be piling up in the city.
It sounds romantic doesn’t it? “Ah, the consumers recycle and compost creating piles of nutrient enriched soil full of minerals and vitamins that they use to grow their roof top gardens of lush, delicious, healthy fruits and vegetables. Happy earth worms, sing and dance all while teaching the healthy children about math, science and the cycle of life in the Utopian Paradise of San Fransisco.”
Recycle – Good idea – make it practical. Government mandates usually backfire in unexpected ways. San Diego was doing a good job of implementing and making the process convenient so people will actively and willingly participate (when I lived there). On the other hand – San Francisco, while probably good intentioned, might consider San Diego’s lead. I have family in S.F and one observation is what is considered normal trash for a family, for a week, is a very small trash can (only one). I guess people are suppose to bury their excess trash, take it to another county, serve it for dinner, who knows. Make recycling practical – educate the people on how to recycle & how to deal with the volume. I have not seen anything different in S.F. – recycled collection – of some things. Other things – such as used paint cans are left to one’s imagination. People need a solution which is convenient, simple, and cheap.
Recycle – OK, let’s start with the San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors. I understand they are experts in fertilizer.
#10 – exactly right – personal freedom is the right to do things that other people might not agree with.
Doing exactly what you’re told to do is not freedom.
As for the recycling and composting issue, there is an obvious business opportunity here: sell recycling and composting services to people who don’t want to do it themselves.
In my apartment building, we have a recycling program – but, in fact, all we actually do is put paper in one bin, plastic containers in another, and glass bottles in another. That’s not recycling – it’s just sorting trash. Later a truck comes buy once a week and picks it up – and they do the actual recycling.
I want three giant trash cans to take out every week instead of just one. Can you imagine what the compost trashcan will smell like? You can’t put the the yucky trash in plastic bags.
I don’t have time to sort stuff out by whatever arcane rules they have for recycling. Is an envelope with a window recyclable? Is hamburger grease compostable and if it is, what container may it be kept in?
I don’t throw that much away anyway. I take a single trash bag out every week or two. I print on both sides of paper, unless I am submitting a manuscript. I read the newspaper at the laundromat, so I never buy the paper. (Just need the coupon section anyway.) The only trash I generate is packaging, food trash, office paper, and junk mail. I called the local paper that gets delivered free into my mailbox and asked them to stop sending it so I could reduce that bit of trash and told the Jehovah’s Witnesses to take their Watchtower magazine with them so I wouldn’t have to through it away.
In my state you can’t recycle pop cans or pop bottles because we return them for a deposit. That is the main recyclable items. (The aluminum actually pays for the cost of recycling programs except in places where people get a deposit or where they can sell the aluminum.)
I walk to work and leave my pickup truck at home. (I started doing that when gas was $3.90 a gallon.) I don’t have air conditioning at home. (by choice)
I don’t want to be forced to recycle, mainly because of the sorting.
#14 Benjamin has a point. Many containers are made up of a combination of materials. Is my fruit juice carton with the pouring spout paper or plastic? What about the plastic container with the aluminum pull tab lid? Recycling can be tricky.
Like I said, I don’t have enough time to sort garbage.
I read the article. It said waxy cardboard i compostable, but regular cardboard is recyclable. What is the difference?
Besides, between hoarding and reusing both sides of most office paper, I throw away very little trash. Mainly kitchen and bathroom trash.
sounds like slavery.
Then, the city will be hiring garbage police to go around looking for violators. I live in this shit hole. I put everything in the black can every week, and I bring back my aluminum cans and get about $7.50 for a couple of small kitchen garbage bags full. SF wants you to just give them to the city, after paying a recycling fee when you buy them. This city is off of the tracks. Fuck them and fuck Al Gore.
I see a future where we will be mining landfills for metals and other such valuables.
Where I live in Canada you have one semi large blue bin
you put recycled stuff in 8$ a month
the city give’s you a refund for a tiny compost you put in your back yard I think its 20 or 30$ total.
Hey, a fine for not recycling might be alright, but a LIEN?! They’re going to take your property away if you don’t recycle? How is that fair?
Um, getsmart, you completely failed to get the point of Idiocracy.
Yes, it did feature giant mountains of trash.
#11
And what do piles of garbage attract – freeloading riff raff.
Not democrats for this example, but cute little chipmunks and squirrels and cute by not so pleasant skunks and not so cute nor pleasant coyotes and dog packs.
With a never ending “food source”, there will be all sorts of riff raff belling up to get the free meal they will soon come to believe they are entitled to…followed shortly by PETA protecting the ‘rights’ of those little rats.
I liked her other shirt: Will fuck for Jesus!
I bet the same people who whine about personal freedom when told to recycle and reduce waste are the same people who defend a granny tazing cop because the granny exercised personal freedom (ok the granny was an asshole but you get my drift).
Deal with your own waste. Don’t make it someone else’s problem. Citing personal freedom to avoid personal responsibility is a cop out.
In my suburb in Oz we have a fairly sensible recycling program which just requires keeping plastic, metal and paper separate, and the local council provides a big wheely bin to dump it all in. There is also a wheely bin for garden waste if you need it.
San Francisco: The Stench by the Bay
Why doesn’t someone tie a plastic shopping bag over the philandering mayor’s head until he’s “GREEN” and then compost his remains?
It would decrease SF’s carbon dioxide.
Just to add to Hugh’s comment, I believe those complaining about “personal freedoms” are the same that complain about saddling our children with debt. Hey, guess what. All that garbage your “personal freedom” makes is being left to OUR children. Grow up and start thinking past your own greedy assholes for once.
#26
Personal Freedom….simple rules that apply to everyone – equally. No one gets a free ride because of their age and no one has to carry a heavier burden because a nutcase wants to be seen as politically correct.
Nothing complicated or hard to understand – unless your trying to see thru the glasses Mr.Fusion is wearing. And then life gets so confusing all you can do is bully and threaten people who disagree.
#28, Rick,
You fail to see that your “personal freedom” stops at our right to live free from your garbage.
Tell you what: If you want to enforce these recycling rules because it makes you feel good to force ME to follow them, then we should go all the way and enforce ALL these freedom limiting rules. A) Put a 1000% tax on alcohol, because we should reduce the number of drunks and then the number of deaths due to drunk driving. Make it too expensive to be a drunk.
2) You cannot have anything but fluroescent lamps in your home. Sorry if you hate that light, sorry if it doesn’t jive with your aesthetic taste. (And trust me, I’ve been in tons of homes in San Francisco where the PC nuts living in them refuse to use fluroscents because ‘I can’t stand them…’
C) No more cars. Cars are not green. Cars must be outlawed in San Francisco. No parking in San Francisco, no driving in San Francisco. Want to own a car? Then park it outside the city and take Muni or the bus to your car when you need it.
D) No bakeries. Bakeries produce things loaded with sugar (which non of us need) and carbs (which make us fat and we can’t have that). So bakeries are gone.
E) No coffee. It’s filled with aromatics and carinogens. Protect people from themselves if they won’t do it for themselves.
#31, Kwad,
Do you have issues because people don’t want to live with your garbage? You do sound like the type of asshole that gleefully throw refuse out the window of you SUV not caring whose lawn it lands on.