|
The media coalition comprised almost all of the major US newspaper publishers and press organisations, including — in addition to the RCFP — the American Society of Newspaper Editors, The Associated Press, the Citizen Media Law Project, The E.W. Scripps Company, the Gannett Company, The Hearst Corporation, the Los Angeles Times, the National Newspaper Association, the Newspaper Association of America, The Radio-Television News Directors Association, and The Society of Professional Journalists…
Faced with such concerted and well founded opposition from the press, Judge White not only dissolved the injunction requiring Dynadot to suppress Wikileaks’ DNS entries but also denied the plaintiff’s request for an order prohibiting the website’s publication.
The article clearly defines the constitutional reasons for overturn. Well done, folks.
There is a possibility the Judge was embarrassed by his obvious hasty and wrong prior decision.
It is one thing to be overturned on appeal. It is another to invite absolute ridicule from the Appeals Court that this decision would have done.
Yes, its the right outcome for the right reasons- – -but- – – -how can a “judge” rule against the first amendment in the first place??
The case remains as a clear benchmark that the constitution is under attack and damaged by the BushCo. How many other less known decisions have whittled away at the more arguable edges? ((I can name a few–mostly centered on increasing the secrecy of governmental actions etc)).
So–it is good, but I’m not happy and no one else should be either. The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. (by somebody)
Yeah! One of those more and more infrequent moments in which I feel proud to be an American.
All systems of goverment are flawed, but only the best can correct their own mistakes so quickly.
I’m glad the judge reversed. Now he should retire due to terminal stupidity…