Signs of a Bubble — Here’s one guys attempt to define the signs of a bubble. He extrapolates on the following 5 items, but I’m not convinced the forumla for identification is correct. I only agree with number one. But with the dotcom bubble I was hearing that two to 3 years before the bubble actually appeared. And, in fact, you hear it all the time in high-tech. Perpetually. Anyway the essay is food for thought, but I think we can do better.
And consider the possibility that the bubble is a cycle and the bubble itself creates much of the phenomenon that later gets analyzed as causative.
5. Little attention to infrastructure problems
4. Poster child can do no wrong
3. Features and me-too solutions
2. Money, money, money
1. “The rules are different now”
1. “The rules are different now”
This definitely doesn’t apply. Paul Krugman has been claiming a bubble and coming depression for years now.
Money was a big part of the tech meltdown. According to George Gilder, the Fed cut back on the supply of venture capital that was needed.
Sounds like the media industries to me.
5. Defence of old distribution model
4. iTunes
3. Napster, Rhapsody, etc.
2. RIAA, MPAA
1. They are.
Those signs may explain the USA as a whole.
The economy, the “war on terror,” the war in Iraq, …
The country shows signs of itself being a bubble. Problems are being ignored because people believe that some divine providence has allowed the country to defy the laws of economics, karma, religion, science, …
Just a thought.
My thought: The dotcom bubble crashed when the California energy crunch put too great a strain on disposable income and business cash flow. Granted the bubble was unstable from greed and speculation, but it was cheap energy that freed up the capital for the bubble to grow.
The energy crunch happened later.